Claims Manager Salary

Claims Manager Salary

Share this post on:

Claims Manager Salary

Have you ever wondered how much claims managers in the insurance industry earn? As a crucial role in processing and resolving insurance claims, claims managers can command strong compensation. But with salaries varying across employers, geographies, experience levels, and other factors, determining average pay and ranges can be tricky.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll give you the full overview of claims manager salary data to help demystify compensation for this career. Whether you’re an aspiring claims adjuster looking to move into management, an insurance professional considering specializing in claims, or simply curious about pay in this field, you’ll find all the key details and insights you need. Let’s dive in!

Average Base Salary and Total Compensation

According to recent data, the average base salary for claims managers lands at around $76,000 per year. With additional compensation like bonuses and profit sharing, total pay averages around $87,000 annually.

To account for pay variability across the field, it’s helpful to look at salary ranges:

  • 10th Percentile: $55,000 base salary
  • 25th Percentile: $68,000 base salary
  • 50th Percentile (Median): $76,000 base salary
  • 75th Percentile: $90,000 base salary
  • 90th Percentile: $113,000 base salary

So while middle earners make around the $76k median base, top performers can earn well into six figures. Factors like experience, employer, industry, and location impact where you land within (or even beyond) this range.

How Salary Progresses with Experience

One of the biggest factors affecting claims manager pay is years on the job. Here’s an overview of how salary grows over the course of a career:

Entry Level (Under 1 Year Experience)

In an entry-level claims manager role, expect a median base pay of approximately $61,000 annually. Total compensation with bonuses and profit sharing averages around $64,000 for professionals just starting out.

Early Career (1-4 Years Experience)

During the first decade in claims management, pay advances steadily with each year of expertise. For those with 1-4 years experience, median base salary reaches around $67,000, with total compensation around $71,000.

See also  What If Repair Cost More Than Insurance Estimate

Mid-Career (5-9 Years Experience)

After 5-9 years overseeing insurance claims, professionals reach median base pay of $79,000. With bonuses and other additional compensation, you can expect to earn around $84,000 annually by this point.

Late Career (10-19 Years Experience)

In the later stages of their career, claims managers become highly specialized experts in insurance claims resolution. During this phase, median base pay reaches approximately $86,000, with total compensation averaging $91,000.

Experienced/Executive (20+ Years Experience)

The most seasoned claims management professionals command the highest earning power. With 20+ years navigating complex claims and honing leadership abilities, median base salary reaches around $92,000. Total compensation climbs further to $98,000 for those at the executive level.

Clearly, investing time to gather broad claims handling experience pays off in earning potential over the long run. Sticking with the career path leads to exciting pay growth.

Top Paying Employers

Certain employers offer more competitive compensation for claims management professionals. Here are the 10 highest paying companies for claims managers by total annual pay:

  1. Genworth Financial – $138,000
  2. AIG – $132,000
  3. MetLife – $126,000
  4. Chubb – $120,000
  5. USAA – $120,000
  6. Beazley Group – $120,000
  7. Mercury General – $118,000
  8. Progressive – $117,000
  9. New York Life – $116,000
  10. Travelers – $116,000

Landing a claims management role with insurers like Progressive, Chubb, or USAA can provide a significant boost in earnings potential. But even smaller or niche carriers like Beazley Group and Mercury General make the top 10 list, showing high pay isn’t limited just to the largest insurers.

Industries With the Highest Pay

Along with your specific employer, the industry you work in impacts salaries for claims managers. The top 5 highest paying industries include:

  • Financial Services – $115,000 median total pay
  • Insurance – $110,000 median total pay
  • Retail & Wholesale – $110,000 median total pay
  • Healthcare – $105,000 median total pay
  • Information Technology – $94,000 median total pay

Roles in banking, investments, or other financial services allow claims managers to earn slightly higher pay compared to the insurance industry itself. But insurance still comes in a strong second, offering excellent compensation potential.

What Factors Most Influence Salary?

What determines where you fall within (or beyond) the average salary range? Here are the key factors influencing claims manager pay:

Experience and Tenure

As discussed above, years of experience dramatically impacts earnings potential. Long tenured claims managers at a single employer also tend to earn more than frequently job-hopping counterparts.

See also  What Is A Scheduling Order

Location and Cost of Living

Your geographic location plays a major role. Those working in major metro areas like New York or San Francisco earn 10-20% higher pay compared to smaller cities due to the higher cost of living.

Education, Certifications, Training

Pursuing higher education and specialized insurance or claims certifications (like ARM, AIC, or AINS) can boost salaries. Ongoing professional training also helps.

Skills and Performance

Strong negotiation, litigation management, and people management skills drive higher pay. Consistently top-notch performance and higher claims closure rates also contribute.

Type and Complexity of Claims

Overseeing complex commercial claims or litigated cases warrants higher compensation than straightforward auto/property claims.

Manager vs Adjuster Role

Moving from an adjuster to manager role usually provides a 15-20% pay bump or more. Supervising teams and processes commands higher pay.

Overtime, Bonuses, Profit Sharing

Pursuing overtime hours as well as bonuses and profit sharing incentives from your employer can significantly increase total compensation.

Industry and Employer

As discussed above, pay varies dramatically by sector and employer based on company size, claim volume, and budget.

The Gender Wage Gap in Claims Management

Among claims managers, women earn median base salaries approximately 5-7% lower than male counterparts. This indicates there is still work to be done improving pay equity and representation. Women also make up nearly 65% of the claims manager workforce, showing a need for greater gender diversity in insurance leadership roles. Slowly but surely, we are seeing employers emphasize inclusive hiring, promotion, and compensation practices to close these gaps.

High Job Satisfaction and Benefits

The good news? Claims managers tend to be quite satisfied in their careers. According to Payscale, claims managers rate their job satisfaction a 4 out of 5 on average. They enjoy nice work-life balance, exciting claims resolution work, and abundant advancement opportunities.

Typical benefits include 3+ weeks of paid vacation, health/dental insurance, retirement savings plans, tuition reimbursement, and flexible work arrangements. Between the high job satisfaction and strong benefits, claims management offers nice perks beyond the pay itself.

Career Growth Trajectories

For claims managers aspiring to advance, what potential promotion paths are there?

  • Claims Director – Oversee all claim departments and staff for an insurer.
  • Compliance/Risk Officer – Ensure sound risk management policies and regulatory compliance.
  • Credit/Collections Director – Lead teams managing insurer debt collections.
  • General Manager – Manage entire regional/branch insurance operations.

With each step up, pay, responsibility, and influence grows. But even just gradually progressing from entry to senior claims manager can boost salary tremendously through added knowledge.

The Bottom Line

While claims manager salaries vary across employers and geographies, typical compensation ranges from around $55,000 for entry level professionals to over $90,000 for experienced managers. Factors like location, tenure, skills, education, and employer impact earning potential. But with high job satisfaction, great benefits, and abundant career growth opportunities, claims management offers nice financial and personal rewards for those who pursue the career path long term.

Share this post on: